Architectural Record
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Subscribe
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Architectural Record
  • NEWS
    • Latest News
    • Awards
    • Interviews
    • Obituaries
    • Podcasts
      • Design:Ed Podcast
      • Sponsored Podcasts
  • OPINION
    • Book Reviews / Excerpts
    • Exhibition Reviews
    • Forum
  • EXCLUSIVES
    • Videos
    • Design Vanguard
    • Top 300 Firms
    • Sponsored Content
    • Sponsored eBooks
    • From the Archives
  • CONTINUING ED
    • Editorial Continuing Ed
    • CE Center
    • CE Academies
  • PROJECTS
    • Buildings By Type
    • Reuse & Renovation
    • Museums & Arts Centers
    • Colleges & Universities
    • Multifamily Housing
    • Interiors
    • Lighting
    • Kitchen & Bath
  • HOUSES
    • Record Houses
    • House of the Month
    • Featured Houses
  • PRODUCTS
    • Products by Category
    • Record Products of the Year
    • Latest Products
  • EVENTS
    • Dates & Events
    • Record on the Road
    • Innovation Conference
    • Sustainability in Practice
    • Women In Architecture
    • Webinars
    • Ad Excellence Awards
    • Submit an Event
  • CONNECT
    • Ask RECORD AI
    • Newsletters
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Editorial Calendar
    • Store
    • Customer Service
  • SUBMIT
    • Submission Guidelines
    • RECORD Competitions
  • MAGAZINE
    • Subscribe
    • My Account
    • Digital Edition
    • Current Issue
    • Firm Pass
    • Historic Archive
Commentary & Criticism

Making monuments right before an era comes to a close

By Robert Campbell, FAIA
April 16, 2009

The Third Law isn’t nearly as universal as the first two, but it does suggest some possibilities. One thinks, for example, of the magnificent railroad stations that were built as late as the 1930s in far-flung American cities like Buffalo and Cincinnati, just as rail was, you’d think predictably, about to give way to the car and the plane. Or think of the imperial architecture of Britain, in London and New Delhi, as the Empire began to weaken in the early years of the 20th century.

Polshek’s Newseum
Photo ' Jeff Goldberg/Esto
Polshek's Newseum opened as newspapers face threats to their survival.

Or to come closer to the present, it’s interesting to someone who, like me, dabbles in journalism to notice that at least three monuments to that profession have recently arisen in the U.S., at the very moment when we’re all abuzz with predictions of the forthcoming demise of the newspaper and the radical reconstruction of other forms of journalism.

The three are the Newseum in Washington, right across the mall from the Capitol, by Polshek Partnership; the New York Times tower in Manhattan, by Renzo Piano; and the Hearst Tower a few blocks away, by Foster and Partners.

I like the Times building and dislike the Hearst, but they’re both, certainly, signature works of architecture you could accuse of expressing our civilization “most pretentiously,” especially given that both the Times and Hearst’s San Francisco Chronicle are deep in debt. As for the Newseum, I’m not sure it would have occurred to anyone to build a museum of journalism when newspapers were still hot stuff. When a culture is thriving, it’s too busy to build monuments because it’s having too much creative fun doing whatever made it a culture in the first place. It’s when things start to slide that you get the backward look.

I don’t want to press this point too hard, but I’ll throw out one more suggestion. Much of the world has been building art museums in recent decades with a passion that rivals the cathedrals of the Middle Ages in Europe. Yet I think it’s entirely fair to say that there has never been a time when people were less certain of what constitutes good art, or less sure whether any such thing is actually being produced today. Are we asking our museums to be themselves works of art because we lack confidence in the quality of the things inside?

Essayists are allowed to follow their thoughts wherever they lead, so let me change the subject. I mentioned the Alhambra as a favorite building. That raises a whole other question, probably unresolvable, which is how much of our appreciation of a work of architecture depends on the circumstance in which we first saw it.

It was February or early March when I first visited Granada, the air clear and bright. My then wife and I were traveling around Europe on a fellowship from Harvard. We registered at a parador, a beautiful monastery converted into a hotel, on the hill a few steps from the Alhambra. It was late in the day and my wife said she wanted to rest, so I walked over to the Alhambra myself. If my memory isn’t playing a trick, I was the only tourist in the building for the next 45 minutes. As I walked freely around, I was struck by an aspect of the Alhambra which now reminds me of the kind of place envisioned in the 1984 classic Collage City, by Colin Rowe and Fred Koetter. Those authors propose a city in which formal, symmetrical public spaces are placed among what otherwise is an intricate, unpredictable world of narrow lanes and changing levels. The Alhambra is famous for its ornamental detail, but what electrified me was the experience of moving among its spaces, both indoor and out, as they opened out or tightened up. As I did so, the sun was slowly setting, deepening the ambers and pinks of the walls. A light rain, almost a mist, began to fall. Surfaces grew reflective and the water features seemed to connect with a larger life.

I never want to go back, because I know the Alhambra can’t again be that same building. It wasn’t, even, on the following morning. I remember, by way of warning, a disastrous attempt to revisit another loved locus, the Italian village of San Gimignano, some years after my first time there. It was so full of tourists — okay, people like me, I recognize — that it felt like crowding myself into a subway at rush hour. The experience of place was no longer attainable.

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

Robert Campbell, FAIA, was architecture critic for the Boston Globe and a longtime RECORD contributor.

Post a comment to this article

Report Abusive Comment

Subscription Center
  • Create an Account
  • Start a Subscription
  • Manage My Account
  • Sign Up for Newsletters
  • Visit Customer Service
  • Update Preferences

More Videos

Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the Architectural Record audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of Architectural Record or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

close
  • TAMLYN XtremeTrim Exterior Trim
    Sponsored byTamlyn

    Designing Cleaner Panel Facades: Why Exterior Trim Details Matter

  • Building with Vapor Barriers
    Sponsored byReef Industries, Inc.

    Vapor Barriers Help Control Moisture in Tighter Building Designs

  • Duct Interior with Prodeq System
    Sponsored byHenry, a Carlisle Company

    Designing Resilient Water Containment Systems

DESIGN:ED Podcast
Listen to Architectural Record’s DESIGN:ED Podcast

Events

June 10, 2026

Rethinking Stormwater – The Power of Porous Paving

Credits: 1 AIA LU/HSW; 1 AIBD P-CE; 0.1 ICC CEU

Learn how porous paving systems support stormwater management, reduce heat island effects, and enhance sustainable site design performance.

June 11, 2026

Very Early Warning Fire Detection for Mission-Critical Facilities

Credits: 1 AIA LU/HSW; 1 AIBD P-CE; 0.1 ICC CEU

Examine advanced fire detection strategies that support uptime and enhance safety in data centers and other mission-critical facilities.

View All Submit An Event

Products

2026 Architect's Square Foot Costbook

2026 Architect's Square Foot Costbook

See More Products

Popular Stories

Coronado Bridge

The Architect’s Guide to San Diego

Practice Matters illustration

What’s in a (Firm’s) Name? Thinking About Succession and Legacy

Practice Matters illustration

By the Numbers: Counting America's Architects

Inward House

Inward House by VeeV Design Studio

Riverdale House by Studio Lau

Riverdale House by Studio Lau

Broader Sustainability of CMU - Free Webinar - May 21, 2026

Related Articles

  • Making monuments right before an era comes to a close

    See More
  • Greenbuild 2017 Closing

    Neil deGrasse Tyson Brings Greenbuild 2017 to a Close

    See More
  • 30-Year Construction Draws to a Close for Skirball Cultural Center in Los Angeles

    See More

Related Products

See More Products
  • 1118978811.gif

    Architectural Design with SketchUp: 3D Modeling, Extensions, BIM, Rendering, Making, and Scripting, 2nd Edition

  • movable arch.jpg

    Movable Architecture: A Design Guide to Container Reuse

See More Products
×

The latest news and information

#1 Source for Architectural Design, News and Products

SUBSCRIBE
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Submit
    • Store
  • ACCOUNT CENTER
    • Create an Account
    • Start a Subscription
    • Manage My Account
    • Sign Up for Newsletters
    • Visit Customer Service
    • Update Preferences
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY
  • SERVICES
    • Marketing Services
    • Reprints
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • Linkedin
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • X (Twitter)

Copyright ©2026. All Rights Reserved BNP Media, Inc. and BNP Media II, LLC.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing