This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
Architectural Record logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Subscribe
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Architectural Record logo
  • NEWS
    • Latest News
    • Interviews
    • Reviews
    • Commentary
    • Editorials
  • PROJECTS
    • Building Types
    • Interior Design
    • Museums & Arts Centers
    • Adaptive Reuse
    • Colleges & Universities
    • Lighting
    • Snapshot
  • HOUSES
    • Record Houses
    • House of the Month
    • Featured Houses
    • Kitchen and Bath
  • PRODUCTS
    • Material World
    • Categories
    • Award Winners
    • Case Studies
    • Partners in Design
    • Trends & Insights
  • EXCLUSIVES
    • Best Architecture Schools
    • Top 300 Firms
    • Theme Issues
    • Record Houses
    • Record Products
    • Good Design Is Good Business
    • Design Vanguard
    • Historical Archive
    • Cocktail Napkin Sketch
    • Videos
  • CALL FOR ENTRIES
    • Record Houses
    • Guess the Architect Contest
    • Submit Your Work
  • CONTINUING ED
    • Architectural Technology
    • Architect Continuing Education
    • Continuing Education Center
    • Digital Academies
  • EVENTS
    • Record on the Road
    • Innovation Conference
    • Women In Architecture
    • Webinars
    • Advertising Excellence Awards
  • MORE
    • Subscribe
    • Customer Service
    • Digital Edition
    • eNewsletter
    • Interactive Spotlight
    • Store
    • Custom Content Marketing
    • Research
    • Sponsor Insights
    • eBooks
  • CONTACT
    • Advertise
Home » Commentary: One-Hit Wonders
Commentary & Criticism

Commentary: One-Hit Wonders

January 16, 2011
Charles Linn, FAIA
Reprints
No Comments

If a client asks you to imitate yourself, is that the sincerest form of flattery?

If you ever think that the architecture business has gotten too tough, you can always lay down your mouse, pick up a guitar, and go into pop music. Architects are problem solvers, right? The best make their livings predicting what people need and what will appeal to them. They produce materials lists and instruction sheets, then contractors follow them, a ribbon is cut, and euphoria ensues.

Illustration
illustration © Norman Hathaway

So it shouldn’t be too hard for us to figure out which noises will inoculate young boys and girls with bliss. At most we are talking about three or four minutes of 4/4 time, three chords, and a snazzy backbeat, all of which can be produced with GarageBand, which Apple gives away free with every Macintosh. Yoke up a catchy tune with a few rhyming couplets alternating mania with despair, and next stop, Hitsville.

All you need is one smash and you’ll be set for life. Well, you will be until someone asks you to do another like it. Then you’re back to the quandary every rock ’n’ roller who’s scored big on his first record faces: let your work evolve, like Dylan going electric, which seemed to please nobody, or be remembered as a one-hit wonder who spent the rest of a brief career cloning his or her best effort to meet the demand for more of the same.

All of this came to mind recently when a colleague posted a blog entry on archrecord.com about a new house Richard Meier had designed for the British actor Rowan Atkinson.

Two commentators easily connected the dots between the Atkinson residence and Meier’s 1968 Smith and 1972 Douglas houses: They’re white, have flat roofs and vast areas of glass, and are sited in the middle of nowhere. They are beautiful. But the general tone of the thread seemed to be that we are really entitled to much more from Mr. Meier than a rehash of early work.

Others seemed surprised that Atkinson, who is perhaps best known for his endearingly incompetent character Mr. Bean, hadn’t ordered something more like Pee-wee Herman’s bizarre, visually frantic playhouse (which was extremely interesting and really quite suitable for its purpose, I think). Ummm, but since Rowan Atkinson is not actually Mr. Bean, what they really meant, perhaps, is that the house might have been much more interesting if Mr. Meier’s client actually had been Mr. Bean. As much as I’d like to see what that house looks like, the idea that Richard Meier somehow owes his clients private residences that are different from those he is known to do and does well strikes me as a little unfair.

Joni Mitchell once said to an audience of whiney concertgoers begging her to play their favorite songs, “Nobody ever said to Van Gogh, ‘Paint A Starry Night again, man.’ He painted it, and that was it.” Well, that might have been true where Vincent was concerned, but you don’t go to Richard Meier to get a polka-dotted blue house.

I have admired Meier’s work since 1968, when a copy of Record with the Smith House on the cover arrived at my parents’ home. I was 11, growing up in tract housing, and the Smith House completely changed my view of the world. The Douglas House showed up on the cover of Progressive Architecture a few years later, just after financial difficulties had forced me into architecture school. (My parents refused to fund a journalism major, because though my father subscribed to these journals, he also famously said, “Nobody ever made a living writing magazine articles.”) Work like Meier’s convinced me that the architecture profession was a pretty good second choice.

Many of us in those days tried to design Meier houses of our own, when we weren’t trying to design Graves houses or Gwathmey houses. The halls of my college were jammed with them. Well, most of us got the color right, but that was about it. Sure, you can imitate someone’s work, but the real geniuses in architecture or music or any of the arts leave an inimitable mark on whatever they do. There’s no getting around it.

In 1966, when the Beatles had abandoned bubblegum and were well on their way to “Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds,” a couple of television producers saw an opportunity to pick up where they left off. They pulled four actors together and put Don Kirshner in charge of fabricating music that did kind of sound like early Beatles. The “band” they created, the Monkees, was a sensation. But there’s no way these genetic engineers could have taken “Last Train to Clarksville,” put it into a test tube, and extracted “Back in the U.S.S.R.” from it.

Incidentally, after a year or two, the Monkees dismissed Kirshner. He is said to have decided that he would never put up with actors again. That is why Kirshner’s next group, the Archies, was made up entirely of comic book characters brought to life through the magic of animation. Their sound was created entirely by studio musicians according to his strict formula that was also very successful — if not original.

The industrialized production of buildings by the best and brightest of our profession isn’t new either, of course, and there is no doubt that we long for our idols to surprise us with something new. But their clients have to want that, too. And I don’t feel sorry for them much, because, frankly, they get what they pay for. The people I really feel for are those who labor in obscurity helping their bosses put out these formulaic buildings. What would you call them? No. No. Don’t say it!

Not Archie Architects!

AR Subscribe

Recent Articles by Charles Linn,

Continuing Education: Colleges & Universities

KU Medical Center Health Education Building by CO Architects

BNIM Offices at Crown Center by BNIM

Charles Linn is a Kansas City–based writer and architect and a former deputy editor of Architectural Record.

Related Articles

RECORD's 11th Annual Innovation Conference to Hit New York City on October 3rd

Toyo Ito Gives Update on Rebuilding Effort in Earthquake-hit Japan

Related Products

World Architecture: The Masterworks

Sustainable Building Design: Principles and Practice

The Experience of Architecture

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

More Videos

AR Tremco Webinar


 


 

Events

December 12, 2019

Improving Building Delivery with BIM

Credits: 1 AIA LU/Elective; 1 AIBD P-CE; 0.1 IACET CEU
May qualify for learning hours through most Canadian architectural associations

BIM brings countless advantages to the construction team, but the biggest benefit lies with the owner. For architects continuing to develop and enhance delivery methods, BIM is the solution. In this webinar with Rob Glisson, AIA, principal at ROJO Architecture, see how BIM can help you reduce risk, accelerate schedules, establish more accurate budgets, decrease costs, and better serve your clients.

December 17, 2019

Minimizing Risk in Blindside Waterproofing Applications

Credits: 1 AIA LU/Elective; 1 AIBD P-CE; 0.1 IACET CEU

May qualify for learning hours through most Canadian architectural associations

This course will identify blindside waterproofing product technologies, their differences, the criteria for product performance, and how to design a waterproofing system accordingly. Best practices for mitigating application risks and managing critical areas prone to moisture infiltration will be reviewed, including the sequence of installation and for detailing failure points.

View All Submit An Event

Products

ENR Square Foot Costbook 2020

ENR Square Foot Costbook 2020

See More Products

Tweets by @ArchRecord

Architectural Record

AR December 2019 Cover

2019 December

In the December 2019 issue, Architectural Record reveals the winners of the annual Record Products contest.

View More Subscribe
  • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Survey And Sample
    • Editorial Calendar
  • Call for Entries
  • Subscribe
    • Subscribe
    • Renew
    • Create Account
    • Change Address
    • Pay My Bill
    • Free eNewsletters
    • Customer Care
  • Advertise
    • Architectural Record
    • Advertising Awards
  • Industry Jobs

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing