New York City, New York

NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital’s dense web of mostly older buildings at its 20-acre campus in Upper Manhattan is not unusual for medical complexes constructed over many decades. Administrators and trustees balk at demolishing old facilities, and so with a nip here and a tuck there structures survive long past their original life expectancies, even as new space is desperately needed. The conundrum motivates these clients and their architects to scour the environs for sites they previously would never have considered.

 

Program

Milstein Hospital is NewYork-Presbyterian’s main inpatient facility. When it opened in 1988, its operating rooms were state-of-the-art, and over the years they have become some of the busiest in the U.S. More than 100 operations may be performed in its 26-room surgical suite in the course of a day.

Surgery and patient care have evolved at light speed since the building opened, thanks in part to new techniques developed in this hospital. Diagnostics machines and complex surgical procedures that would have been considered science fiction when the building opened are common today and continue to advance rapidly.

But to keep leading the way, Milstein needed new kinds of spaces — for example, hybrid operating rooms that could quickly change from noninvasive to invasive surgery if a patient had problems in the midst of a seemingly routine procedure.  But where could it expand?

Solution

The site of the new Vivian and Seymour Milstein Family Heart Center was carved out of a schist outcropping so large it was considered unusable until the real estate became too valuable to ignore. The addition fills a void between Milstein Hospital and the Herbert Irving Pavilion, an early 1960s vintage medical office building.

Patients and visitors can gain access to the Heart Center via its entrance on a side street, which is somewhat private and gives the center its own identity, or they can enter by way of Milstein Hospital’s more public main lobby (considered the addition’s first level) and through a compact but beautifully daylit four-story atrium. It is spanned by bridges on three levels, connecting Irving to Milstein.

The new facility packs a tremendous amount into a small space. A conference center with prefunction space, an auditorium and four meeting rooms, is located on the first level. Labs and radiology occupy the level below the conference center, and a cath lab is located on level two. Eight new operating rooms have been added on the third level, and diagnostics, such as echocardiograms, are performed on level four. On level five, 20 ICU rooms have been added. Functions on all these floors have been seamlessly integrated into the existing hospital, while its circulation was improved.

Commentary

On the whole, hospital additions are more difficult to extract pleasing moments from than most building types. Obstacles range from woeful existing conditions to clients who resist spending money on frills like waiting rooms. The architects in charge of this project, Ian Bader, FAIA, of Pei Cobb Freed & Partners, and Chip Calcagni, AIA, of daSILVA Architects, were privileged to have generous donors and an enlightened client in NewYork-Presbyterian’s senior vice president, Andria Castellanos. And they are to be commended for what they’ve made of it. The addition has earned a LEED Gold rating, and its exterior stands out like a jewel between two beige monoliths that were depressing at best. Innovations such as the cable-truss, double-walled facade that frames the south elevation bless the waiting rooms and conference center with spectacular views of the Hudson River. The glass bridges over the atrium are also more than eye candy. They reconcile the differences in floor heights between Irving and Milstein and can cut critical minutes of travel time between the buildings when a quick response to an emergency is required.

One of the huge challenges for these architects was anticipating how rooms not yet built could accommodate equipment not yet invented. Although their solutions are not visible to the eye, the firms devoted much attention to ensuring that the structural system as well as utility and data lines are adaptable enough to support what may be science fiction today, but commonplace in the near future.

Completion Date: January 2010

Owner: NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital

Total construction cost: $140 million

Gross square footage: 165,000 sq.ft. (new construction), 40,000 sq.ft. (renovation)

Architect:
Pei Cobb Freed & Partners Architects LLP
88 Pine Street
New York, NY  10005
Tel:  212-751-3122
Fax: 212-872-5443

People

Owner
NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital

Architect
Pei Cobb Freed & Partners Architects LLP
88 Pine Street
New York, NY  10005
Tel:  212-751-3122
Fax: 212-872-5443

Personnel in architect's firm who should receive special credit:
Ian Bader FAIA LEED, Partner-in-Charge, Design
Michael D. Flynn FAIA, Partner, Technology
Alan Gordon AIA, Associate Partner, Management, Project Architect
Richard Cutter AIA, Associate Partner, Job Captain
Michael Lyon, Associate
Apisit Thanavuthiporn AIA LEED, Associate
Jenny Yoo, Associate
Jian Hei, Associate
Keunsook Suk LEED, Staff Architect

Associate architect
daSILVA Architects
Charles L. Calcagni AIA, Principal
Anton Martinez AIA, Principal
Susan Romano

Interior design:
Pei Cobb Freed & Partners Architects LLP

Landscape architect:
Pei Cobb Freed & Partners Architects LLP
Andre Morawski RA ASLA, Associate Partner, Landscape

Engineer(s):
Structural:
Thornton-Tomasetti
Aine M. Brazil, Principal
Michael J. Squarzini
Ken Tuttle

MEP:
Syska Hennessy Group
G. Venkata Ramu
Ernie Brandusa
Amedeo Moino

Consultant(s):
Hospital Planning Programming: 
Medical Planning Research International
Raymond Skorupa

Project Manager:  Peter J. Romano & Company               

LEED Consultant:  EME Group Consulting Engineers

Vertical Transportation:  Van Deusen & Associates

Acoustical:Cerami & Associates, Inc.

Code:  Code Consultants Professional Engineers, P.C.

Audio/Visual:  Center for Biomedical Communications / AV Services, Columbia University

Specifications Writer:  Construction Specifications, Inc.

Zoning/Expeditor:  Municipal Expediting Inc.

Surveyors: 
Lovell & Belcher Inc. City Surveyors
Badey & Watson Surveying & Engineering, P.C.

General contractor:  
Construction Manager:  Bovis Lend Lease, LMB, Inc.

Trade Managers:
Taggart Associates Corp.
KSW
                         
Photographer
Paul Warchol   
Phone: 212-431-3461  
Fax: 212-274-1953
requests@warcholphotography.com
warcholphotography.com

Renderer: Pei Cobb Freed & Partners Architects LLP

CAD system, project management, or other software used: Autodesk, AutoCAD, 3D Studio Max

 

Products

Structural system
Steel frame

Exterior cladding
Masonry:
Infill / Replacement Brick:
Watsontown Brick Co. Vulcan Smooth w/ Iron Spots

Tri-State Brick & Building Materials
151 West 25th St.
New York, NY 10001

Granite Wall Base & Paving Border:
Chelmsford Grey Granite, Thermal Finish

Fabricator:
Fletcher Granite Co., Inc.
Westford, MA 01886

Installer:
Port Morris tile & Marble Corp.
1285 Oak Point Ave.
Bronx, NY 10474

Moisture barrier:
Henry Company
909 N. Sepulveda Blvd., Suite 650
El Segundo, CA 90245-2724

BK021 – Bakor Air Bloc 21
Blueskin SA (Self-Adhesive Air/Vapor Barrier Membrane)

Double walled façade:
Climate Wall Glazing and  Support Hardware:
Pilkington Planar by W&W

W&W Glass Systems, Inc.
302 Airport Executive Park
Nanuet, NY 10954-5285
Exterior Vertical Glass:
25 mm Laminated Glass (15mm Pilkington Optiwhite T-Plus, 1.52 PVB, 8mm Optiwhite H/S)

Exterior Roof Glass:
25 mm Laminated Glass (15mm Pilkington Optiwhite T-Plus, 1.52 PVB, 8mm Optiwhite T-Plus)

Exterior Soffit Glass:
25 mm Laminated Glass (15mm Pilkington Optiwhite T-Plus, 1.52 SGP, 8mm Optiwhite T-Plus)

Interior Vertical Glass:
44mm Insulated, Laminated, Tempered, Heat-Soaked Units (6mm Optiwhite T-Plus, 16mm air, 10mm Optiwhite T-Plus, 1.52mm SGP, 10mm Optiwhite T-Plus)

Pilkington Stainless Steel Hardware:
Pilkington 902 glass support hardware in type 316 stainless steel
Pilkington 905 glass support hardware in type 316 stainless steel
Pilkington castings in type ASTM A890 grade 4A Duplex stainless steel with a fine grit blast, pickled and electro polished finish

Climate Wall Support Trusses:
TriPyramid Structures, Inc.
59 Power Road
Westford, MA 01886

Stainless Steel Rod Trusses:
TPS horizontal support struts: type 304 stainless steel, ASTM A276 grade S30400, #4 linear finish
TPS rods: ASTM A276 grade S30400 cold drawn
Hardware: 304 stainless steel, ASTM A276 grade S30400, #4 linear finish
Tensioning clevis assemblies: stainless steel at exposed surfaces, #4 linear finish
Standard fasteners: 304 or 18-8 stainless steel
Metric fasteners: grade A2-70 stainless steel

Reynobond Aluminum Composite Panel System:
4mm FR (fire rated) Reynobond aluminum composite panel, Pewter finish

Supplier:
Alcoa Cladding Systems
555 Guthridge Court
Norcross, GA 30092

Fabricator:
IDA International, Inc.
200 Roosevelt Drive
Derby, CT 06418

Exposed painted steel support brackets:
Painted with Duranar XL UC51713XL Pewter
Sealant:

Dow Corning 795 silicone (grey)

Motorized Fabric Shading Devices:
Manufacturer:
Nysan Solar Control
#1 115 28 Street SE
Calgary, AB, T2A 5K4

Installer:
The DK Group
10 E. 39th Street, Suite 1123
New York, NY 10016

PANEL SYSTEM (EXCLUSIVE OF CLIMATE WALL)
Reynobond Aluminum Composite Panel System:
4mm FR (fire rated) Reynobond aluminum composite panel, Champagne Metallic finish

Supplier:
Alcoa Cladding Systems
555 Guthridge Court
Norcross, GA 30092

Fabricator:
IDA International, Inc.
200 Roosevelt Drive
Derby, CT 06418

Exterior Wall Cavity Insulation:
Roxul CavityRock 2" Thick

Supplier:
Roxul Inc.
420 Bronte St. S., Suite 105
Milton, ON L9T 0H9

Roofing
Elastomeric:
MM6125 EV Monolithic Membrane

Supplier:
American Hydrotech, Inc.
303 East Ohio St.
Chicago, IL 60611-3387

Installer:
Eagle One Roofing Contractor, Inc.
18-60 45th St.
Astoria, NY 11105

Windows
Aluminum:
EFCO, A Pella Company
PO Box 609
Monett, MO 65708-0609

Glazing
Glass:
Storefront Entrance:
Pilkington Optiwhite T-Plus (Laminated)

Atrium Vertical Wall / Climate Wall:
Pilkington Optiwhite T-Plus (Laminated, Insulated Units with 40% black frit dot pattern)

Punched Windows:
Oldcastle BuildingEnvelope Glass Insulating Glass Units with Sunguard SN-68 on #2 surface

Canopy:
Pilikington Optiwhite T (laminated with custom frit pattern)

Skylights:
Pilkington Optiwhite T-Plus (laminated, Insulated Units with 60% black frit dot pattern)

Insulated-panel or plastic glazing:  See panel system info

Doors
Entrances:
Glass & Stainless Steel Storefront Doors:
J.E. Berkowitz, L.P.
One Gateway Boulevard
Pedricktown, N.J. 08067

Glass & Stainless Steel Revolving Door:
Crane Revolving Doors
924 Sherwood Drive
Lake Bluff, IL 60044

Metal doors:
Hollow Metal Doors:
Long Island Fireproof Door, Inc.
5 Harbor Park Dr.
Port Washington, NY 11050

Wood doors:
Interior Wood Doors:
Petersen Geller Spurge, Inc.
32 Hickory Lane
Hudson, NY 12534

Fire-control doors, security grilles:
Long Island Fireproof Door, Inc.
5 Harbor Park Dr.
Port Washington, NY 11050

Upswinging doors, other:
The Bilco Company
P.O. Box 1203
New Haven, CT 06505 U.S.A.

Interior finishes
Acoustical ceilings:
Ceilencio Custom Acoustical Panel Ceiling System with Claro Finish:
Decoustics Limited
61 Royal Group Crescent
Woodbridge, Ontario Canada L4H 1X9

Suspension grid:
Acoustic Ceiling Tile:
Armstrong World Industries
2500 Columbia Ave. (17603)
P.O. Box 3001
Lancaster, PA 17604

Cabinetwork and custom woodwork:
Petersen Geller Spurge, Inc.
32 Hickory Lane
Hudson, NY 12534

Paints and stains:
Benjamin Moore & Co.
101 Paragon Drive
Montvale NJ 07645

Paneling:
Wood Veneer Wall Panels:
Petersen Geller Spurge, Inc.
32 Hickory Lane
Hudson, NY 12534

Acoustical Wood Veener Wall Panels:
Madero (Solo M, Type 32 – 16mm thick FR NAUF MDF with figured Anegre quarter-cut and book-matched)

Decoustics Limited
61 Royal Group Crescent
Woodbridge, Ontario Canada L4H 1X9

Special surfacing:
Corian – Venaro White

Du Pont
E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company
1007 Market St.
Wilmington, DE 19898

Floor and wall tile:
Daltile & American Olean Ceramic Tile

Public Toilets (walls & floors)
Staff Toilets (walls & floors)
Housekeeping (walls & floors)

Daltile Corporation
7834 C.F. Hawn Frwy.
Dallas, TX 75217

Resilient flooring:
Armstrong World Industries
2500 Columbia Ave. (17603)
P.O. Box 3001
Lancaster, PA 17604

TOLI International
55 Mall Drive
Commack, NY 11725

Special interior finishes unique to this project:
Travertine Walls & Floor:
Mariotti Carlo & Figli s.p.a.
Via Tiburtina 287
00011 Tivoli Terme
Rome, Italy

Epoxy & Venetian Terrazzo Flooring:
D. Magnan & Co, Inc.
32 Cortlandt St.
Mt. Vernon, NY 10550

Resilient Terrazzo Tile:
Fritztile
500 N. Sam Houston Rd.
Mesquite, TX 75149

Conveyance
Elevators/Escalators:
Elevators:
City Elevator
45 Main St.
Suite 844
Brooklyn, NY 11201

Elevator Cab Finishes:
National Elevator Cab & Door Corp.
53-13 37th Ave.
Woodside, NY 11377

Accessibility provision (lifts, ramping, etc.):Manufacturer:
Services Industriels Savaria, Inc.
107 Alfred Kuehne Boulevard
Brampton, Ontario L6T 4K3  Canada

Installer:
Mobility Elevator & Lift Co.
4 York Ave.
West Caldwell, NJ 07006-6407