Not so long ago, one of the most compelling reasons for daylighting a space was energy savings. Since the 1970s, lighting has been one of the largest users of electricity in buildings. But advances in lighting technology, namely the rapid improvement of LEDs, which are longer-lasting and more efficient than more traditional sources, are changing the discussion. Lighting’s energy consumption has been on the decline, representing 17 percent of electricity end use in commercial buildings in 2012, according to the U.S. Energy Information Association, down from 38 percent in 2003. Electric illumination’s slice of the energy pie should fall even more as LEDs develop further and their controls become both more sophisticated and more user-friendly.
Of course, there are other arguments for designing around daylight. Architects have intuitively understood its ability to elevate the experience of their interiors. Now an increasing body of science, accumulated over decades, has quantified daylighting’s beneficial effects. One still frequently cited 1999 study examined schools in three U.S. districts and found significantly improved performance among students occupying daylit classrooms. Since then, research has demonstrated higher sales figures in skylit big-box stores, as well as better outcomes for patients in hospital rooms with daylight, including shortened stays, reduced need for pain medication, and quicker post-op recovery.
Design teams and their clients are showing renewed interest in such health and productivity benefits. One chief factor is the expansion of the green building movement to encompass occupant well-being in addition to energy efficiency, says Chad Groshart, lighting-design lead in the New Haven office of Atelier Ten, an environmental design consultant: “The focus is no longer only on how the meter is spinning.”
One attribute of daylight that architects are keen to harness is its ability to help regulate our biological clocks, or circadian rhythms. Its spectral distribution and intensity affect a host of interrelated physiological and psychological functions including mood, alertness, and hormone levels. Designers are also eager to use electric light to improve these functions, a possibility enabled by the advent of tunable-white LEDs, which have color temperatures that can range from very warm to very cool. But experts warn that there is still debate about the optimum color, timing, and duration of exposure in such electric illumination. “Circadian lighting design is more of a lengthy experiment rather than an authoritative design standard,” says Brian Stacy, Arup’s lighting lead for the Americas. Groshart echoes this view: “Sunlight is the best circadian light,” he says, advising that project teams seeking to help regulate occupants’ internal rhythms should first focus on strategies for achieving the best quality daylight, including the orientation, form, and fenestration of the architecture.
Such factors can be readily manipulated when designing a new building, but tenant fit-out projects or the renovation of existing buildings naturally require a different approach. An example is one of Groshart’s own projects, the New York headquarters for Delos, the wellness real-estate and technology company best known for creating the WELL Building Standard (the rating system is now administered by Green Business Certification Inc.). Delos moved into its space on the fourth and fifth floors of 860 Washington Street, a new 10-story structure by James Carpenter Design Associates and Adamson Associates Architects in the city’s Meatpacking District in late 2017. The organization picked the building in large part for its floor-to-ceiling glass curtain wall on three of its four facades, since both daylight and views are important aspects of WELL. This skin affords ample daylight and views of the adjacent High Line park and the rest of the neighborhood. (The offices have been certified WELL Platinum, have earned Living Building Challenge “petal” status, and are on track for a LEED Gold or Platinum rating.)
The project’s architect, Gensler, with Atelier Ten as lighting designer, developed the 19,000-square-foot office with a variety of environments, including “free address” workstations, a café, and meeting and focus rooms, all organized around a central stair featuring a digital artwork that is activated as occupants ascend or descend. At least 75 percent of the space is within 25 feet of a window, representing a daylighting asset, but also a challenge due to the potential for glare and the developer’s prohibition against adding exterior shading devices or altering the glass with frits or films. Instead, the problem was addressed with perforated roller shades and careful placement of computer screens in relation to the curtain wall.
The electric-illumination scheme is designed to supplement available daylight and emulate some of its qualities. The tunable-white LED luminaires throughout the office are controlled via an astronomical clock, changing their correlated color temperature (a metric that defines the color appearance of an LED and is measured in degrees Kelvin) throughout the day. Meanwhile, photo sensors dim the LEDs’ intensity, depending on the amount of available sunlight. The wireless system allows for tightly defined zones as well as the ability for manual override in meeting and training rooms, so that employees can adapt the lighting to specific tasks and preferences.
The Delos team is evaluating the effectiveness of the space’s WELL features, including this tunable lighting system, with its own staff as test subjects. It is using a variety of means, such as periodic surveys and cognitive studies. Once the data have been analyzed, the company plans to release the results, according to Janna Wandzilak, a Delos vice president and a manager of the construction project.
When planning its new offices on the 18th through 20th floors in the Wilshire Grand, in downtown Los Angeles, Arup had to contend with constraints similar to those faced by Delos. This recently completed 73-story mixed-use tower, designed by AC Martin, rises to a sail-shaped pinnacle. The engineering firm could not alter the building envelope, and its tenant agreement required that a particular type of roller shade be used for sun control. But the firm wanted to make the most of available sunlight, projecting it as far as possible into the floor plate. Arup also wanted to avoid glare in order to minimize the time the shades would be drawn, obstructing views of the city.
In order to achieve these goals, the project team, which included Bestor Architecture and SmithGroup, with Arup in charge of lighting and engineering, developed an interior light shelf at the building’s long, slightly bowed south facade. The device, made of drywall, is suspended from the ceiling approximately 8 feet above the finished floor, with each shelf spanning more than 27 feet between columns. Four feet deep and 5 inches thick, to accommodate the required roller blind, the light shelf shields the workstations from direct sunlight while bouncing it to the exposed structural deck above, which has been sprayed with white acoustical insulation to achieve a light-reflectance value of 85 percent. The strategy “allows us to transform the ceiling plane into a luminaire,” says Liberty MacDougall, an Arup senior lighting consultant.
The light shelf’s configuration, dimensions, and placement were arrived at after rigorous examination not typical for a tenant fit-out project, according to MacDougall. This analysis included parametric modeling, taking into account such factors as: the light transmittance of the glazing; the height and location of work surfaces, material finishes, and colors; and the surrounding buildings that block access to sunlight. In addition, the team erected a full-scale mock-up, in a single bay of the 18th floor, to physically test its capabilities, but also to demonstrate to the Wilshire’s owner that, from the exterior, Arup’s offices would be indistinguishable from those of other tenants.
The firm, which moved into the space in the middle of April, expects that at least 83.75 percent of open office workstations will receive enough daylight (30 foot candles) to make electric illumination unnecessary for at least half of the annual occupied hours. The innovative aspect of the scheme, according to MacDougall, is that it fuses daylight with electric lighting. For those times when the sun is not adequate, a linear LED lamp, incorporated into the top of the light shelf, along with a pendant LED luminaire suspended over a circulation zone, near the core, will be in use.
Both electric-illumination sources are indirect, relying on the ceiling to reflect light and enhance the perceived brightness, explains MacDougall. Both sources are also tunable, adjusting, like the LEDs at Delos, via time-clock controls and photo sensors, to qualitatively align with the spectral distribution and intensity of the daylight bouncing off the light shelf.
Tunable systems are occasionally used as a proxy for daylight in spaces without access to sunlight. This is not always for occupant health or productivity reasons, but instead to enhance experiential qualities. Such was the case with the creation of a 1,600-square-foot gallery for First Nations’ artifacts at the Museum of Anthropology at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver. The room, a former theater in an early-1970s Arthur Erickson building, had only one small, north-facing window. Although the situation was desirable from a conservation standpoint—many of the objects are fragile and vulnerable to UV degradation—it was less than ideal for museum visitors, since most of the treasures, which include carvings, textiles, and basketry, are best appreciated under daylight.
Stantec, along with AES Engineering for the lighting and electrical design, created a “skylit” room that mimics the actual daylight outside. A shallow, 4-foot-wide cove was built at the perimeter, concealed by stretched PVC. Above the translucent surface are tunable white LEDs, hung from the existing slab at an angle. The configuration—arrived at both through simulation and physical mock-ups—helped maximize the distance between PVC and the lamp, and allowed the backlit surface to glow uniformly without the individual lamps’ being discernible, explains Doug McMillan, a lighting designer at AES. The center of the ceiling includes some track lighting, while the display vitrines incorporate organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs), well suited to confined spaces. But most of the gallery’s lighting is provided by the luminous cove and its LEDs, connected to a DMX controller (a digital communication network first created for theatrical lighting) and a roof-mounted sensor that reads correlated color temperature and illumination levels. Since there was no off-the-shelf sensor available that measured both attributes and met other project requirements, the team made its own device with parts that included a camera sensor. The apparatus takes a reading every three minutes, gradually shifting from cool to warm to cool over the course of the day and registering changing weather conditions, diminishing the brightness in the gallery when it is cloudy. The installation is so successful claims McMillan, that museum-goers sometimes visit the space multiple times in a single day to view an object under different light.
Although McMillan’s gallery-lighting scheme seeks to emulate daylight rather than augment it, the Vancouver project, like the offices of Delos in New York and Arup in Los Angeles, illustrates a shift toward closer integration between outdoor and indoor light conditions, and between natural and electric light. In the future, we will surely see, in both new construction and renovations, tighter coordination of daylighting with artificial illumination—a trend that will only enrich occupant experience.
To earn one AIA learning unit (LU), including one hour of health, safety, and welfare (HSW) credit, read "Continuing Education: Daylight and Electric Illumination," review the supplemental material listed below, and complete the online test. Upon passing the test, you will receive a certificate of completion, and your credit will be automatically reported to the AIA. Additional information regarding credit-reporting and continuing-education requirements can be found online at continuingeducation.bnpmedia.com.
“Daylighting in Schools: An investigation into the Relationship Between Daylighting and Human Performance,” Condensed Report, Heschong Mahone Group, 1999, Daylighting Initiative. (“Executive Summary,” pages 3-4; “Discussions and Conclusions,” Pages 25-30.)
1. Explain why energy efficiency is less of a motivator for daylighting than it once was.
2. Discuss studies that link daylighting to improved occupant health and productivity.
3. Discuss the role of light in regulating circadian rhythms.
4. Explain how tunable-white LEDs can replicate or augment some of the qualities of sunlight.
AIA/CES Course #K1905A
For CEU credit, read "Continuing Education: Daylight and Electric Illumination" and take the quiz at continuingeducation.bnpmedia.com, or use our Architectural Record Continuing Education app, available in the iTunes store.
Post a comment to this article
Report Abusive Comment